The Complete Guide to Commercial Tenant Screening for GTA Landlords

Why Tenant Screening Matters More in Commercial

Residential tenant screening is relatively straightforward—credit check, employment verification, landlord references. Commercial tenant screening is far more complex because the stakes are higher.

A bad residential tenant might cost you a few months' rent. A bad commercial tenant can cost you:

• - Years of below-market rent locked into a lease
• Costly tenant improvements that can't be recovered
• Damage to your property that affects other tenants
• Legal fees for eviction or collections
• Months of vacancy after they leave
• Reputation damage to your property

Thorough screening upfront prevents these costly problems.

The Four Pillars of Commercial Tenant Screening

Effective screening evaluates four key areas:

1. Financial Capacity

Can this tenant reliably pay rent for the full lease term?

For Established Businesses:

- Business financial statements (3 years minimum) - Look for consistent revenue and positive cash flow - Calculate rent-to-revenue ratio (should be under 10% for retail, varies by industry) - Review trends—growing, stable, or declining?

- Business tax returns (2-3 years) - Verify income matches financial statements - Look for consistency year over year

- Bank statements (6-12 months) - Verify stated revenue flows through the account - Look for consistent balances - Watch for NSF fees or overdrafts

- Accounts receivable and payable aging - Are they collecting from customers? - Are they paying suppliers on time?

For New Businesses:

New businesses lack operating history, so focus on:

- Business plan review - Are projections realistic? - Does the concept make sense for this location? - What's their competitive advantage?

- Startup capital - How much capital are they starting with? - Can they survive slow initial months? - Source of funds (personal savings, investors, loans)?

- Owner's experience - Have they operated a similar business before? - Industry experience even if not ownership? - Supporting team experience?

2. Personal Guarantor Strength

Commercial leases to corporations or LLCs should include personal guarantees. The guarantee is only as good as the guarantor.

What to Obtain:

• - **Personal financial statement** (net worth statement)
• **Personal tax returns** (2-3 years)
• **Credit report**
• **Proof of assets** (especially liquid assets)

What to Look For:

• - **Net worth** sufficient to cover lease obligations
• **Liquid assets** (cash, marketable securities) for near-term obligations
• **Income sources** beyond the business
• **Existing liabilities** that could impair ability to pay
• **Credit history** showing responsible debt management

Red Flags:

• - Net worth concentrated in illiquid assets (primary residence)
• High existing debt loads
• Recent bankruptcies or judgments
• Reluctance to provide complete information

3. Business Viability

Will this business succeed in your space?

Concept Fit:

• - Is this use appropriate for your property?
• Does the location serve their customer base?
• Is there sufficient parking and access?
• Are there conflicts with existing tenants?

Market Analysis:

• - Is there demand for their product/service in this area?
• Who is their competition, and how close?
• What's their competitive advantage?
• Is the industry growing or declining?

Track Record:

• - How long have they been in business?
• Performance at other locations?
• Industry reputation?
• References from suppliers, customers, previous landlords?

4. Landlord and Legal History

Past behavior predicts future behavior.

Previous Landlord References:

Don't just call the current landlord (who may be motivated to get rid of them). Call:

• - Two landlords before current
• Landlords from failed locations
• Landlords of related businesses owned by the principals

Questions to Ask:

• - Did they pay rent on time?
• How was their maintenance of the space?
• Any lease violations or disputes?
• Would you rent to them again?
• How did they leave the space at move-out?

Legal History:

• - Court records for evictions or landlord-tenant disputes
• Judgments or liens against the business or principals
• Bankruptcy filings (business or personal)
• Business license status and history

Red Flags That Should Concern You

Some warning signs warrant extra scrutiny or declining the application:

• **Immediate Red Flags:**
• Refusal to provide financial information
• Previous evictions from commercial spaces
• Recent bankruptcy (within 3-5 years)
• Judgments from previous landlords
• Inconsistencies in information provided

• **Yellow Flags (Investigate Further):**
• New business with inexperienced operators
• Business concept that seems unrealistic
• Rushing to close the deal quickly
• Asking to waive or reduce standard lease terms
• Unable to provide complete documentation
• Multiple business failures (even if not evictions)

Context Matters:

A yellow flag isn't automatic disqualification. A new restaurant from an experienced restaurateur is different from a first-time operator. Context and totality of circumstances matter.

Documentation Checklist

Request these documents before making a leasing decision:

• **From the Business:**
• [ ] Business financial statements (3 years or since inception)
• [ ] Business tax returns (3 years)
• [ ] Bank statements (12 months)
• [ ] Articles of incorporation/organization
• [ ] Certificate of good standing
• [ ] Business license
• [ ] List of principals/members/officers
• [ ] Business plan (for new businesses)

• **From Personal Guarantors:**
• [ ] Personal financial statement
• [ ] Personal tax returns (2-3 years)
• [ ] Credit authorization form
• [ ] Government ID
• [ ] Proof of assets if significant (bank statements, investment accounts)

• **References:**
• [ ] Previous landlord contact information
• [ ] Bank reference letter
• [ ] Trade/supplier references
• [ ] Professional references

Adjusting Terms Based on Risk

Not every tenant needs the same lease terms. Higher-risk tenants require more protection:

• **For Strong Tenants (established, well-capitalized):**
• Standard security deposit (1-2 months)
• Standard personal guarantee terms
• May negotiate some tenant-favorable provisions

• **For Moderate-Risk Tenants:**
• Higher security deposit (3-4 months)
• Full personal guarantee for lease term
• Stricter default provisions
• More frequent financial reporting

• **For Higher-Risk Tenants (new businesses, weaker financials):**
• Maximum security deposit (6 months or more)
• Strong personal guarantee with asset verification
• Shorter initial term with renewal options
• Monthly financial reporting
• Landlord-favorable termination rights
• Consider higher rent to offset risk

The Screening Process Timeline

A thorough screening process takes time. Build this into your leasing timeline:

• **Day 1-3: Initial Application**
• Receive completed application
• Collect application fee
• Verify basic information

• **Day 4-10: Document Collection**
• Request and receive financial documents
• Obtain credit authorization
• Collect guarantor information

• **Day 10-15: Verification and Analysis**
• Pull credit reports
• Call references
• Analyze financials
• Research legal history

• **Day 15-20: Decision and Negotiation**
• Make approval decision
• Determine appropriate terms
• Negotiate final lease terms

Total: 2-3 weeks minimum

Rushing this process is how landlords end up with problem tenants.

Using a Professional for Tenant Screening

While you can conduct screening yourself, working with a commercial broker provides advantages:

• - Experience recognizing red flags
• Established screening processes
• Access to reference networks
• Objective third-party perspective
• Documentation of due diligence
• Negotiation of protective terms

The cost of professional help is minimal compared to the cost of a bad tenant.

When to Say No

Sometimes the best deal is the one you don't make. Decline an applicant when:

• - Financial capacity is clearly insufficient
• Personal guarantee would be meaningless
• Business concept is fundamentally flawed for your location
• Red flags can't be explained or mitigated
• Your instincts are consistently negative
• Risk mitigation would require unreasonable terms

A vacant space costs less than a bad tenant.

Get Professional Leasing Support

Proper tenant screening is essential to protecting your commercial property investment. Our landlord representation services include thorough tenant qualification to ensure you get quality tenants with appropriate lease terms.

Learn about our landlord leasing services